Peanut Butter & Jelly (23 Results)

Filter By

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases

using the BJ's One+™ Mastercard^®.

Learn More

with no risk to your credit score

Earn 5% back in rewards

on most BJ’s purchases¹.

Check if you’re pre-approved

with no risk to your

credit score.

Learn More

Sort & Filter
Coupons
Instant Rebates
Free Shipping
Reset

Sort By

Relevance

Grid
List

Best Seller

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

$2.00 off

2750

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Sponsored

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

PBfit Classic Roasted Peanut Powder, 8g Protein Per Serving, 30oz

165

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Best Seller

^$5³⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Welch's Grape Jelly, 2 pk./30 oz.

304

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Best Seller

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, Jars, 2 pk./48 oz.

4000

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$15⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Creamy Hazelnut Spread, Breakfast Favorite, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

328

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Strawberry Preserves, 2 pk./32 oz.

400

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Top Rated

^$9²⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 36 oz.

523

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Top Rated

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

$2.00 off

1753

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$10⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves, 26 oz.

$2.00 off

374

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$9⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 ct./26 oz.

333

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Top Rated

^$3⁹⁹

$4.99

$1.00 (20%) Off

Instant Savings

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme, Jars, 2 pk./13 oz.

1528

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Nostalgic Favorite 📼

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Crofter's Organic Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

167

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

^$16⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella & Go! Hazelnut Spread with Breadsticks, On-the-Go Snack Cups, 16 ct./1.8 oz.

253

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$9⁴⁹

$10.49

$1.00

Instant Savings

SNAP EBT Eligible

Stonewall Kitchen Wild Maine Blueberry Jam, 30 oz.

224

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Top Rated

^$14⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Chunky Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

$2.00 off

2114

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella B-Ready Wafer Bars, Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Individually Wrapped Snack Bar, 36 ct.

277

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
FREEShipping

^$7⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Almond Butter with Sea Salt, 27 oz.

348

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cinnamon Jam, 30.5 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Top Rated

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz

971

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$9⁹⁹

Mayte Dulces De Leche Caramel Spread, 2 pk./16 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$5⁹⁸

SNAP EBT Eligible

SunButter Jammies Sunflower Butter & Grape Jelly Sandwiches, 12 ct.

Currently Unavailable

^$6⁹⁹

Mayte Guava Paste, 3 pk./1 lb.

Currently Unavailable

^$7⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Chocolate Hazelnut Spread, 26.5 oz.

Currently Unavailable

Showing 23 of 23 Results

^$17⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nestle Toll House Semi-Sweet Chocolate Morsels, Chocolate Chips, Gluten Free, 72 oz.

$1.00 off

(3157)

^$15⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Creamy Hazelnut Spread, Breakfast Favorite, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

(328)

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

$2.00 off

(2750)

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Strawberry Preserves, 2 pk./32 oz.

(400)

^$4⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Goober Grape, Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Stripes, Jar, 30 oz.

(26)

^$6⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Welch's Organic Grape Spread, 45 oz.

(74)

^$9²⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Premium Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 10 IB

(505)

^$7⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Gold Medal Flour, 12 lbs.

$2.25 off

(364)

^$8²⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Pearl Milling Company Original Pancake Syrup, 64 oz.

(550)

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Grade A Dark Maple Syrup, 32 oz.

$1.50 off

(707)

^$3⁹⁹

~~$4.99~~

$1.00 (20%) Off

Instant Savings

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme, Jars, 2 pk./13 oz.

(1528)

^$5³⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Welch's Grape Jelly, 2 pk./30 oz.

(304)

^$6⁹⁹

Mayte Guava Paste, 3 pk./1 lb.

(9)

^$13⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 2pk 48 oz.

(35)

^$5⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Domino Light Brown Sugar, 4 lbs.

$1.00 off 2

(197)

^$5²⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Domino Confectioners Sugar, 4 lbs.

$1.00 off 2

(264)

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Pure Vanilla Extract, 16 oz.

(283)

^$14⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nature Nate's Raw US Honey, 40 oz.

$3.00 off

(266)

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

$2.00 off

(1753)

^$10⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves, 26 oz.

$2.00 off

(374)

^$11⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Betty Crocker Hershey's Triple Chocolate Brownie Mix, Bakes 80 Brownies, 5 lbs.

$2.00 off

(362)

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

King Arthur All Purpose Unbleached Flour, 12 lbs.

(2900)

^$16⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Pecan Halves, 2 lbs.

(498)

^$17⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nestle Tollhouse Milk Chocolate Morsels, 57.5 oz.

$1.00 off

(325)

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Crofter's Organic Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

(167)

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

PBfit Classic Roasted Peanut Powder, 8g Protein Per Serving, 30oz.

(165)

^$12⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Cane Sugar, 10 lbs.

$1.00 off

(413)

New Lower Price

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Betty Crocker Bisquick Baking and Pancake Mix, Makes 155 Pancakes, 96 oz.

$2.25 off

(359)

^$11⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Sun-Maid California Sun-Dried Raisins, 2 pk./2 lbs.

$1.50 off

(397)

^$5⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Planters Unsalted Dry Roasted Peanuts, 35 oz.

$2.00 off

(425)

Peanut Butter & Jelly (23 Results)

^$17⁹⁹

^$15⁴⁹

^$13⁷⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$4⁹⁹

^$6⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$7⁹⁹

^$8²⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$3⁹⁹

^$5³⁹

^$6⁹⁹

^$13⁴⁹

^$5⁹⁹

^$5²⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$14⁹⁹

^$13⁷⁹

^$10⁴⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$16⁹⁹

^$17⁴⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$12⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$5⁹⁹

Membership

Customer Care

Quick Links

Corporate

Peanut Butter & Jelly (23 Results)

$1799

$1549

$1379

$1149

$499

$699

$929

$799

$829

$1599

$399

$539

$699

$1349

$599

$529

$1599

$1499

$1379

$1049

$1199

$1099

$1699

$1749

$899

$1099

$1299

$899

$1199

$599

^$17⁹⁹

^$15⁴⁹

^$13⁷⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$4⁹⁹

^$6⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$7⁹⁹

^$8²⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$3⁹⁹

^$5³⁹

^$6⁹⁹

^$13⁴⁹

^$5⁹⁹

^$5²⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$14⁹⁹

^$13⁷⁹

^$10⁴⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$16⁹⁹

^$17⁴⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$12⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$5⁹⁹