Peanut Butter & Jelly (21 Results)

Filter By

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases

using the BJ's One+™ Mastercard^®.

Learn More

with no risk to your credit score

Earn 5% back in rewards

on most BJ’s purchases¹.

Check if you’re pre-approved

with no risk to your

credit score.

Learn More

Sort & Filter
Flat Rate Ship
Coupons
Free Shipping
Reset

Sort By

Relevance

Grid
List

^$9⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves, 26 oz.

364

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Sponsored

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

PBfit Classic Roasted Peanut Powder, 8g Protein Per Serving, 30oz

144

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$9⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 ct./26 oz.

$1.65 off

311

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

^$16⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella & Go Bulk Pack, Hazelnut and Cocoa Spread with Breadsticks, Snack Cups, 16 ct./1.8 oz.

$3.00 off

230

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$10⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Stonewall Kitchen Wild Maine Blueberry Jam, 30 oz.

197

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Top Rated

^$9²⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 36 oz.

502

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Top Rated

^$13⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, Jars, 2 pk./48 oz.

3992

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$15⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa for Breakfast, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

322

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Top Rated

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

1752

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella B-Ready, Snack Bars, Hazelnut Spread With Cocoa, Individually Wrapped, Snack Bar Box, 36 ct.

259

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
FREEShipping

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Crofter's Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

$1.00 off

135

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Top Rated

^$13⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz

966

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$7⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Almond Butter with Sea Salt, 27 oz.

$1.00 off

340

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker Strawberry Preserves, 2pk 32 oz.

398

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

^$11⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif To Go Creamy Peanut Butter, Smooth and Creamy Texture, Snack Size Packs, 36 pk./1.5 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Top Rated

Nostalgic Favorite 📼

^$4⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme, Jars, 2 pk./13 oz.

1528

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

Top Rated

^$14⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Chunky Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

2112

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Flat-Rate Shipping

Nostalgic Favorite 📼

^$4⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Goober Grape, Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Stripes, Jar, 30 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to 44094
Shipping

^$7⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Chocolate Hazelnut Spread, 26.5 oz.

Currently Unavailable

Showing 21 of 21 Results

^$9⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 ct./26 oz.

(311)

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

(1752)

^$11⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Purely Elizabeth Ancient Grain Granola Gluten Free Non-GMO Organic Original, 24 oz.

(293)

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

General Mills Honey Nut Cheerios, 55 oz.

(1035)

^$1⁵⁹

$0.53/pound

SNAP EBT Eligible

Bananas, 3 lbs.

(3183)

^$3⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Mini Cucumbers, 8 ct.

(1225)

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

PBfit Classic Roasted Peanut Powder, 8g Protein Per Serving, 30oz.

(144)

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Crofter's Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

(135)

^$11⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nature's Bakery Strawberry Oatmeal Crumble Bars, 20 ct./1.41 oz.

(256)

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Brekki Vanilla Cinnamon Overnight Oats Breakfast Bowl, 6 pk.

(235)

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms by Nellie's Free Range Eggs, 24 ct.

(880)

^$1⁵⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Chiquita Organic Bananas, 2 lbs.

(636)

^$16⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella & Go Bulk Pack, Hazelnut and Cocoa Spread with Breadsticks, Snack Cups, 16 ct./1.8 oz.

(230)

^$10⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Stonewall Kitchen Wild Maine Blueberry Jam, 30 oz.

(197)

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Kellogg's Special K with Berries Cereal, 2 pk.

(448)

^$9⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

General Mills Cheerios, 40.7 oz.

(923)

^$6⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Hass Avocados, 5 ct.

(1018)

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Eggland's Best Cage Free Large White Eggs, 2 pk./12 ct.

(1254)

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella B-Ready, Snack Bars, Hazelnut Spread With Cocoa, Individually Wrapped, Snack Bar Box, 36 ct.

(259)

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker Strawberry Preserves, 2pk 32 oz.

(398)

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

belVita Blueberry Breakfast Biscuits, 25 pk./1.76 oz.

(440)

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Swiss Granola, 2 lbs.

(468)

^$9²⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 36 oz.

(502)

^$3⁸⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Lemons, 2 lbs.

(1257)

^$5³⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Welch's Grape Jelly, 2 pk./30 oz.

(294)

^$11⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Kellogg's Raisin Bran Breakfast Cereal, 2 pk.

(1332)

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Quaker Oats Quick 1-Minute Oats, 2 pk./5 lbs.

(328)

^$9⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Rao's Homemade Marinara Sauce, 2 pk./22 oz.

(395)

^$4⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Blueberries, 18 oz.

(2981)

^$6⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Cap'n Crunch's Crunch Berries Sweetened Corn & Oat Cereal, 2 pk./20 oz.

(286)

Peanut Butter & Jelly (21 Results)

^$9⁷⁹

^$13⁷⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$1⁵⁹

^$3⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$1⁵⁹

^$16⁹⁹

^$10⁴⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$9⁹⁹

^$6⁴⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$3⁸⁹

^$5³⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$9⁹⁹

^$4⁹⁹

^$6⁹⁹

Membership

Customer Care

Quick Links

Corporate

Peanut Butter & Jelly (21 Results)

$979

$1379

$1199

$1149

$159

$399

$1099

$899

$1199

$1099

$899

$159

$1699

$1049

$1149

$999

$649

$899

$1599

$1149

$1599

$1099

$929

$389

$539

$1199

$1099

$999

$499

$699

^$9⁷⁹

^$13⁷⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$1⁵⁹

^$3⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$1⁵⁹

^$16⁹⁹

^$10⁴⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$9⁹⁹

^$6⁴⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$15⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$3⁸⁹

^$5³⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$9⁹⁹

^$4⁹⁹

^$6⁹⁹