Collectible Surprise Toys(17 Results)
Delivery Options
Special Offers
Age Range
Average Rating
Price Range
Product Type
Brands
Gender
Color
Indoor/Outdoor
Universe
Character
Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases
using the BJ's One+™ Mastercard®.
Learn More
Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.
Check if you’re pre-approved
with no risk to your
credit score.
Learn More
Sort & Filter
$1499
$18.99
$4.00 (21%) Off
Instant Savings
10% off
Pickup at Willoughby- Delivery to
FREEShipping
$1199
$14.99
$3.00 (20%) Off
Instant Savings
CrystaLynx Gecko 9" Collectible Articulated Gecko Toy Figure
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
Member Only Price
Smashers Dino Mania Surprise Egg
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
Member Only Price
Rainbocorns Eggzania Fairy Mania
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1799
$19.99
$2.00 (10%) Off
Instant Savings
MGA's Miniverse Make It Mini Spaces Ice Cream Shop
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1799
$19.99
$2.00 (10%) Off
Instant Savings
MGA's Miniverse Make It Mini Spaces Pizza Shop
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$2399
$26.99
$3.00 (11%) Off
Instant Savings
Disney Duckalooz Mega Pack, 2 Surprise Ducks, 24pcs.
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
Member Only Price
Mini Brands Vinyl Playset & Capsule 2 pk.
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1299
Monboo Cute Pet Dessert Shop Blind Box Collectible Plush Doll
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1299
Laura Girl Cute Pet Dessert Shop Blind Box Collectible Plush Doll
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
Member Only Price
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1999
Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Jumbo Mystery Capsule, 12pcs, 11 Surprises
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1299
Mr. PA Cute Pet Dessert Shop Blind Box Collectible Plush Doll
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1999
Disney Stitch Jumbo Mystery Capsule, 10 Surprise Pieces
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$1299
Mr. PA Cute Pet Dessert Shop Blind Box Collectible Plush Doll
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
$998
$29.99
$20.01 (66%) Off
Clearance
MGA's Miniverse Make It Mini Spring Multipack, Resin Play
10% off- Pickup at Willoughby
- Delivery to
- FREEShipping
Showing 17 of 17 Results
Shop the Best Collectible & Surprise Toys at BJ’s Wholesale Club
Unwrap the excitement with BJ’s collection of surprise toys and collectible figures—a must-have for kids who love mystery and fun! Whether it's a blind box, mini figurine, or limited-edition collectible, these toys deliver thrilling unboxing experiences every time.
Our curated selection features:
-
Popular surprise toy brands like Zuru Pets Alive, Disney, and more
-
Mystery packs and blind bags filled with unique characters
-
Collectible series perfect for trading, displaying, or gifting
Ideal for birthdays, rewards, or just-because treats, collectible and surprise toys spark imagination and keep playtime exciting. Shop now to discover the latest drops and enjoy exclusive BJ’s member pricing.
