$1199
ADD TO LISTEarn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.
Check if you’re pre-approved
with no risk to your
credit score.
Learn More
Smart Summary
Recognition from the U.S. Championship Cheese Contest validates exceptional quality and taste excellence.
Extended Aging
Twelve months of patient natural aging develops the distinctive citrusy sharpness and rich complexity.
Product Overview
Product Features:
Product Warnings and Restrictions:
(Model 1237)
Product information is provided by the supplier and BJ’s does not represent or warrant the information is accurate or complete. Always consult the product’s labels, warnings, and instructions before use. Please see additional terms atbjs.com/termsofuseMost Liked Positive Review
Better Cheddar
Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a cheese head's dream. It's incredibly sharp and full of flavor, with a rich and creamy texture that melts beautifully. Whether you're using it in a grilled cheese sandwich, or just enjoying it on its own, this cheese holds its own. I like using it ...
Most Liked Negative Review
The orange Extra Sharp Cheese has quality consistency issues
I use this product for shredding and adding to pizza, casseroles, pasta meals. The quality recently has become inconsistent, sometimes a bit rubbery, and more recently (when I accidentally grabbed this rather than what I mention in the last sentence), overly salty and VERY crumbly - making it diffi...
Customers say
Overall sentiment is strongly positive, with reviewers consistently praising the sharp, tangy cheddar flavor and its smooth texture that works well for cooking and everyday snacking. A small number of past complaints point to inconsistent texture (rubbery/crumblier) or reduced flavor when the cheese isn’t aged as expected, but most people find it a reliable, versatile staple for mac and cheese, sandwiches, and melting.
Reviewed by 274 customers
Good cheese
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
Great price on a delishous cheese
Best sharp cheddar cheese ever.
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
I love cheese and I keep it on hand all the time. I thought I would give this brand a try and so glad I did. I love the smooth sharp taste. I will definitely buy this cheese again.
Tasty
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
Great flavor and texture. This will be a staple going forward.
Big fan
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
Big fan of Cabot products. All their cheeses are delicious and we love their whip cream as well. The brick of cheddar is our favorite. We like to shred it ourselves for nachos or tacos or slice off a piece for a grilled cheese or an egg sandwich. Which ever way you "slice" it, ha see what I did there … it's delicious! #sweepstakes
Great taste!
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
This is the first time I tried this brand and was pleasantly surprised. I used it in macaroni and it was great. Also good for grilled cheese sandwiches.
Best cheese ever
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
I love this cheddar cheese! For some reason the larger ones in BJ's than the regular size you get in grocery stores tastes better.
Great Extra Sharp Cheddar.
Verified Buyer
This is a perfect Extra Sharp Cheddar. It has a low moisture content. Very flavorful.
#sweepstakes
Verified Buyer
Excellent flavor Good value
Tasty extra sharp
Verified Buyer
I like a sharp cheddar that you can taste - this delivered. A dryer cheese which I like since I don't care for mushy cheese.
Creamy goodness
Verified Buyer
I like cubing this and making a pasta salad. I also slice it to snack on. It has a creamy flavor with a hint of sharpness that makes it easy to eat without a cracker. It goes fast so I'll need to get more next time so that I have more for my pasta salad.
| Cheese Type | Block Cheese |
|---|---|
| Count | 1 |
| Egg-Free | Yes |
| Fat-Free | No |
| Flavors | Cheese |
| Individually-Packaged Portions | No |
| Lactose-Free | Yes |
| Milk-Free | No |
| Model Number | 1237 |
| Net Weight | 1.5 lbs. |
| Product Type | Specialty Cheese |
| Seasoned | No |
| Sugar-Free | No |
| Vegetarian | Yes |
| GSC | 2038305 |
| Preparation | Block |
| Quantity | 1.5 lbs. |
| Country of Origin | USA |
| Allergen Risk(s) | Dairy |
| Gluten Free | Yes |
| Ingredients | Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes |
| Kosher | Yes |
| Lactose Free | Yes |
| Low Sodium | No |
| Number of People Served | Approximately 12 |
| Organic | No |
| Serving Size | 2 oz. |
| Vegan | No |
| Item Length | 1.50" |
| Item Width | 7.22" |
| Item Height | 3.70" |
| Weight | 24 oz. |
| upc | 78354712375 |
Cabot Naturally Aged Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1.5 lbs.
