Special Offer Available: $8.00 off 2. Expires: 11/30/2026
Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.
Check if you’re pre-approved
with no risk to your
credit score.
Learn More
Product Overview
Product Features:
Product Warnings and Restrictions: Government Warning: (1) According To The Surgeon General, Women Should Not Drink Alcoholic Beverages During Pregnancy Because Of The Risk Of Birth Defects. (2) Consumption Of Alcoholic Beverages Impairs Your Ability To Drive A Car Or Operate Machinery, And May Cause Health Problems.
Customers say
Overall sentiment is strongly positive, with reviewers consistently praising the whiskey’s smooth, enjoyable taste and versatility (straight, on the rocks, as shots, and in mixers). Many also highlight the strong value and frequent re-purchase, plus a few mention using it for baking or pairing it with other desserts.
Reviewed by 16 customers
Screwball, can't beat BJ's price, even in New Hampshire
Verified Buyer
Comments about Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey, 750ml
Love this stuff, BJ's always has it in stock at the lowest price. They make it so easy to buy three at a time, ready for two months from now to refill. Thanks, BJ's!
Excellent
Verified Buyer
Delicious...peanut-buttery😋👍🏾
Smooth sweet tasting whiskey
Verified Buyer
So many ways to enjoy this sweet whiskey. Sip it chilled, add to hot chocolate or coffee.
#sweepstakes - LOVE this stuff
Verified Buyer
#sweepstakes - I bought this for my son for Christmas after he gave me a shot on Thanksgiving! I Love it!
Sooo good
Verified Buyer
Great straight or as a mixer.
Too delicious!
Verified Buyer
My wife drank the entire bottle in one sitting.
BJ's is the place to buy screwball
Verified Buyer
This is the best drink, usually drink don't drink the hard stuff, but it's so smooth and at least 35% alcohol. BJ's always has the best price!
Liquid peanut butter
Verified Buyer
This liquor goes great with crown royal chocolate. It's liquid Reese's pieces in a glass
Tasty
Verified Buyer
We really enjoyed this. Sipping over ice
A little PB for a great day
Verified Buyer
This drink is nice and refreshing with a little ice I go to bjs to buy it's due to the always has and available and the best price I can find
| Caffeinated | No |
|---|---|
| Count | 1 |
| Quantity | 750ml |
| Refrigerate After Opening | No |
| Size (L) | Other Measurement |
| Variety Pack | No |
| upc | 860265002405 |
| Product Type | Liquor |
| GSC | 2044174 |
| ABV (%) | 35 |
| Packaging Type | Bottle |
| Aged | No |
| Flavors | Other |
| Liquor Type | Whiskey |
| Liquor Style | Ready to Drink Whiskey |
| Net Weight | 3.42 |
| Non-Alcoholic | No |
| Size (mL) | 750 |
| Includes | Peanut Butter Whiskey, 750ml |
