$799
Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.
Check if you’re pre-approved
with no risk to your
credit score.
Learn More
Product Overview
Product Features:
Ingredients: Sweet Potato, Sugar, Water, Wheat flour, Palm Oil, Eggs, Food Starch-Modified, Contains 1% or Less: Nonfat Milk, Butter (Cream, Water, Salt), Graham Flour, Molasses, Honey, Salt, Baking Soda, Dextrose, Corn Starch, Carob Bean Gum, Cellulose Gum, Agar, Carrageenan, Potassium Chloride, Mono- and Diglycerides, Potassium Sorbate (Preservative), Natural & Artificial Flavors, Sorbic Acid (Preservative), Citric Acid.
Product Warnings and Restrictions: Contains Wheat, Eggs, and Milk. Contains Bioengineered Food Ingredients. May Contain Wheat, Soy, Peanut, Egg, Tree Nuts, Milk, And Sesame.
Most Liked Positive Review
Baked sweet potato pie
This sweet potato pie is the perfect size for entertaining or a family gathering dessert. The filling is smooth and creamy as it should. After living down south for several years and tasting traditional sweet potato pie, I would say that the spice ratio is off a little. However, the pie was very fla...
Most Liked Negative Review
Mediocre Pie!
I would rate this pie as just mediocre. If you're not able to bake your own or get a better tasting pie from for example, Sara Lee or Mrs. Smith's, then this would suffice if entertaining for the holidays. It definitely by far would NOT be my first choice though. The pie is very, very bland tasting.
Customers say
Overall sentiment is mostly positive, with many reviewers praising the sweet potato flavor, rich/creamy filling, and good holiday results when you need a quick alternative to homemade. Some reviewers, however, report texture issues (too mushy/loose or jello-like), overly sweet flavor, and occasional bland/off flavors that can make it miss “true” sweet potato pie.
Reviewed by 187 customers
Delicious Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
For a family meal.
Best Pie Ever
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
This sweet potato pie was the absolutely freakin best store bought pie I have ever eaten. This pie tasted home made like my grandmother used to make. It was fresh, not over sweet and simply delicious.
Sweet Dessert
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
This product is great and easy to serve. A sweet product for family gatherings and for a snack
Good price
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
But not very pumpkinny……..
The best sweet potato pie
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
The best tasting pie, outside of homemade is at BJ'S,
Sweet potato pie
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
Very disappointed the crust was not cooked the batter was okay would not recommend it
Better that all the Rest
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
After I'm slicing the whole sweet potato pie, eating it with everymeal. I realized I needed to share, so I took two nice pieces of the pie to my daughter's house and I tried to check on her family within days, but it was too late that pie was already gone.
Delicious!!!
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
The pue is delicious and decadent. Yum!
🤔
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
It had a strange distinguish taste. It didn't have that sweet potato flavor. BJs is not known for tasty items in their bakery. I won't be a repeat offender on this item
Very tasty
Verified Buyer
Comments about Wellsley Farms Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 10"
Well made goes great with your favorite ice cream.
| Customizable | No |
|---|---|
| Egg-Free | No |
| Fat-Free | No |
| Individually-Packaged Portions | No |
| Lactose-Free | No |
| Low-Carb | No |
| Milk-Free | No |
| No High-Fructose Corn Syrup | Yes |
| No Preservatives | No |
| No Sugar Added | No |
| Number Of People Served | 08/10/2025 |
| Paleo-Friendly | No |
| Refrigerated | No |
| Sugar-Free | No |
| Vegetarian | Yes |
| Wheat-Free | No |
| Whole Grain | No |
| Count | 1 |
| Product Warnings | Contains Wheat, Eggs, and Milk. Contains Bioengineered Food Ingredients. May Contain Wheat, Soy, Peanut, Egg, Tree Nuts, Milk, And Sesame. |
| Quantity | 10" |
| Type | Pie |
| Warranty | 100% Money Back Guarantee |
| GSC | 2040213 |
| Flavors | Other |
| Serving Size | 1 Slice (126g) |
| Number of People Served | 9 |
| Organic | No |
| Kosher | Yes |
| Gluten-Free | No |
| Ingredients | See Above |
| Country of Origin | USA |
| Includes | Sweet Potato Pie, 10" |
| Item Dimensions | 10-Inch Diameter |
