Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

Item: 259906
(374)
Q & A (2)

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.

Check if you’re pre-approved

with no risk to your

credit score.

Learn More

Earn up to 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1. Check if you’re pre-approved.

with no risk to your credit score.

Learn More

Smart Summary

Generated by AI
Quick Preparation
Transforms from freezer to family dinner in just 35 minutes, eliminating lengthy meal prep without sacrificing authentic Italian quality.

Premium Cheeses
Features five artisan Italian cheeses including aged Parmesan Reggiano and Pecorino Romano, delivering restaurant-quality flavor complexity in every bite.
View More
Members Also Viewed
(30 Items)
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...

Product Overview

Details
Wellsley Farms Stuffed Shells use only the very best semolina and the freshest ingredients. That's how we are able to provide simply the best Italian food conveniently packaged so you can enjoy the old world taste of Italy in your own home. Wellsley Farms Five Cheese blend of Ricotta, Asiago, Parmesan Reggiano, Pecorino Romano, and Mozzarella will excite your tastebuds, and pairs great with any sauce. These stuffed shells are easily prepared in 20 minutes.

Product Features:

  • No artificial ingredients
  • High in protein
  • Premium five cheese blend
  • Traditional old world style stuffed shells
  • Includes 4 lbs. of five cheese stuffed shells

    Ingredients: Pasta Ingredients: #1 Semolina Wheat Flour (Niacin, Ferrous Sulfate, Thiamine, Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Water, Pasteurized Liquid Whole Eggs, Dough Mix [Yellow Corn Flour, Vegetable Oil (Soybean or Corn), Apo-Carotenal (Color), Beta-Carotene (Color), Olresin]. Filling Ingredients Contain One or More of the Following: Ricotta Cheese (Pasteurized Milk, Whey, Milk Fat, Salt, Vinegar), Asiago Cheese [(Made From Cow's Milk), Culture, Rennet, Salt, Cellulose Added As Anti- Caking Agent], Parmesan Cheese (Pasteurized Part-Skim Milk, Cheese Culture, Salt, Enzymes), Romano Cheese (Pasteurized Sheep's Milk, Cheese Culture, Salt, Enzymes, Modified Food Starch And Powdered Cellulose Added To Prevent Caking), Low Moisture Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheese (Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Culture, Salt, Enzymes, Potato Starch & Powdered Cellulose To Prevent Caking), Salt, Black Pepper, Parsley

    Product Warnings and Restrictions: Allergen Statement: Contains Egg, Milk, Soy, Wheat

  • Shipping & Returns
    Reviews (374)
    4.8 out of 5

    Review Snapshot

    4.8
    374 ReviewsWrite a Review
    97%
    of respondents would recommend this to a friend

    Ratings Distribution

    Most Liked Positive Review

    Buono!!! Mangia; Mangia…

    I've been buying these frozen stuffed shells for years. The taste is superb and it's hard to believe that it's not homemade because the texture and flavor is stupendous! There's a good amount of ricotta cheese filling stuffed into the shells. All you need to do is prepare your own tomato sauce with ...

    Versus

    Most Liked Negative Review

    Horrible

    The shells are as hard as a rock no matter how long or how you cook them. Followed the directions (which are wrong) when I cooked the first 2/3 of the bag and they were in there over an hour and we just wanted to eat at that point. When I cooked the last 1/3 of the bag, I tried defrosting them first...

    Customers say

    Overall sentiment is mostly positive, with many reviewers praising the stuffed shells for tasting great and being a simple, convenient alternative to cooking from scratch. A smaller number of reviews report major quality issues—off flavors/smell, bland or dry filling, and baking instructions that can leave shells undercooked or rubbery.

    Reviewed by 374 customers

    Still frozen after following directions

    Submitted 9 days ago

    By Chrissie

    From Lenox, ma

    Followed directions exactly and shells are still frozen in the middle. Temperature reads 30° not even close to the target 165°

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Stuffed Shells..

    Submitted 17 days ago

    By Sburke659

    From New Jersey

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    The stuffed shells are as good as anything you can make homemade. Just make yourself a nice pot of homemade sauce. There always very good in a pinch.

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    The count is inaccurate

    Submitted 20 days ago

    By Maureen D Murphy

    From 1568 Meriden Rd, Apt 7H Waterbury CT

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    I was doing a church dinner. Our minister got married on October 4th and we were celebrating on October 18th after church. I had one bag of stuffed shells that I bought end of April and I figured since it said serving 1 shell and 28 in bag, I will pick up another bag of them and it would be enough. We were expecting 54 people.. I got it ready Sunday morning before church. 3 trays with 18 in each tray but I poured sauce in bottom of 3 trays. I had 22 in each bag. Do you really think 6 less in each bag is correct advertising. 22 in each bag bought less than 6 months apart. That is so wrong. I was embarassed.. you are charging $17.99 for this and think it is a blanted rip off

    Member Care Response

    Hello, we sincerely apologize for any trouble you may have experienced with the item. We are currently assisting you through email. We appreciate your patience and understanding. Thank you.

    Bottom Line No, I would not recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Tastes Great

    Submitted 28 days ago

    By Stormin

    From Cumming GA

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    These taste as good as homemade. #sweepstakes

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Really good

    Submitted 1 month ago

    By Lola

    From Homestead

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    My husband and I love this product. Totally recommend it #sweepstakes

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Good stuff

    Submitted 2 months ago

    By Shawn

    From Cherry Hill, NJ

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    I used the stuffed shells for dinner when I was super tired and they were a hit!

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    will buy again

    Submitted 2 months ago

    By Kat

    From DE

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    For not being my homemade, these are the second best. Add your homemade sauce and no one will know the these weren't made by hand. Simply delicious

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Tastes like homemade

    Submitted 2 months ago

    By Stormin

    From Cumming GA

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    These are the best stuff shells I have ever had. When you eat them you can't believe they were frozen. Ingredients tastes fresh and shells are in perfect condition every time.

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Delicious, cheesy, and super easy dinner!

    Submitted 2 months ago

    By Kelly

    From Fort Worth

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    These stuffed shells are an absolute lifesaver for quick, satisfying dinners! The five-cheese filling is rich, creamy, and wonderfully seasoned, while the pasta cooks up to a perfect tender texture. Just place them in a baking dish, cover with your favorite marinara sauce and a little extra mozzarella, and bake. The 4 lb. bag provides plenty of food for a big family meal or easy leftovers. Great quality and fantastic bulk value!

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Shells

    Submitted 2 months ago

    By Jaeboog

    From Sanford

    Verified Buyer

    Comments about Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.

    There are so good my family love it

    Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

    Was this review helpful to you?

    Specifications
    Count1
    Egg-FreeNo
    Fat-FreeNo
    Gluten-FreeNo
    Individually-Packaged PortionsNo
    Kid-FriendlyYes
    Lactose-FreeNo
    Low-CarbNo
    Low-SodiumNo
    Milk-FreeNo
    Net Weight4 lbs.
    No Artificial ColorsYes
    No Artificial FlavorsYes
    No High-Fructose Corn SyrupYes
    No PreservativesYes
    No Sugar AddedYes
    Nut-FreeYes
    Paleo-FriendlyNo
    Plant-BasedNo
    Product TypeFrozen Meals
    Quantity4 lbs.
    Raw FoodNo
    Shellfish-FreeYes
    Sugar-FreeNo
    Tree-Nut FreeYes
    VegetarianNo
    Warranty100% Money Back Guarantee
    Wheat-FreeNo
    World KitchenItalian
    Estimated Delivery3-5 Business Days
    GSC2038305
    IngredientsSee Description
    KosherNo
    OrganicNo
    VeganNo
    Includes4 lbs. of Five Cheese Stuffed Shells
    Item Dimensions4.375"L x 9"W x 13.5"H
    Item Weight4 lbs.
    upc888670000000
    Q&A
    More to Explore
    (30 Items)
    mgctlbxN$MSC mgctlbxV$2.0.55 mgctlbxL$C
    mgctlbxN$MZP mgctlbxV$5.3.7 mgctlbxL$C
    Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.
    Wellsley Farms Five Cheese Stuffed Shells, 4 lbs.