$899
Available Coupons
$2.50 off
(1) Cabot Creamery Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 24 pk. OR 24 oz.
Expires: 11/11/2026
Change Club
In Stock 
Meat Department 
ADD TO LISTEarn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.
Check if you’re pre-approved
with no risk to your
credit score.
Learn More
Smart Summary
This cheese earned 1st Place at the U.S. Cheese Contest, confirming its exceptional quality through independent competitive evaluation.
14-Month Aging
Extended natural aging develops the complex, intensely sharp flavor profile and firm texture that defines premium cheddar.
Product Overview
Product Features:
Ingredients:
Fresh pasteurized milk, cheese cultures, salt, enzymes.
Product Warnings and Restrictions:Avoid dairy allergies
Product information is provided by the supplier and BJ’s does not represent or warrant the information is accurate or complete. Always consult the product’s labels, warnings, and instructions before use. Please see additional terms atbjs.com/termsofuseMost Liked Positive Review
Great texture and flavor, responsive company
For a brief time period in early 2026, the texture and flavor of this cheese was disappointing, after several years of buying the product. I contacted Cabot, and they promptly apologized, said that they suspected storage issues after the time that the product left their handling, then sent me coupo...
Most Liked Negative Review
Very surprised and disappointed
It was advertised as seriously sharp…it wasn't even sharp cheddar. I have bought many Cabot products and have been very satisfied. This cheese was disappointing, period.
Customers say
Overall sentiment is strongly positive, with most reviewers praising the cheese’s bold/“seriously sharp” flavor, creamy tangy texture, and versatility for snacking and cooking. A small number of reviews say it falls short on sharpness or has an off/dry taste in some batches or past purchases.
Reviewed by 359 customers
Cabot is among the best cheeses
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
Always good cheese. We use it most for cheese and cracker appetizers but also great for grilled cheese sandwiches and scrambled eggs.
Best cheddar!
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
I mean, how can you rate any Cabot cheese anything under 5 stars? And for under $7 for the pound…. Cmon! One of the items that we grab every time we go to the club. Now if I could only find an easy way to eat it on the way home….
Cabot Seriously Sharp
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
I enjoyed using this cheese in Mac and cheese. I also, enjoyed eating this cheese by itself or with crackers. This cheese is very creamy.
Great Cheese
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
If you like really sharp cheddar you will definately like this cheese. The price was good, but good cheese is always pricey.
Yummy!
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
This is a very pleasant sharp cheddar cheese. We often just cut a few thin slices to enjoy. Great for adding into eggs for the flavor and creaminess.
This is 'Seriously' good cheese.
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
This is a great multi-purpose cheese that can be used for Mac n cheese, snacks, grilled cheese. The only cheese I like better is Wellsley Farms 3-year aged cheddar.
Great texture and flavor, responsive company
Verified Buyer
Comments about Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
For a brief time period in early 2026, the texture and flavor of this cheese was disappointing, after several years of buying the product. I contacted Cabot, and they promptly apologized, said that they suspected storage issues after the time that the product left their handling, then sent me coupons for the twice the number of cheese blocks that I had found substandard. As of this summer, the product is once again excellent - perhaps the trucking company that handled transport was the culprit for the poor quality blocks.
Cabot Cheese!
Verified Buyer
Love the flavor and the texture. This cheese seems to go with everything. We always have extra in the refrigerator.
Cabot seriously sharp red package is the best!!!
Verified Buyer
Cabot seriously sharp cheddar cheese with the red label (not the blue) is my cheese of choice when entertaining.
We can't stop eating this
Verified Buyer
This is a great tasting sharp cheddar
| Count | 1 |
|---|---|
| Egg-Free | Yes |
| Fat-Free | No |
| Flavors | Cheese |
| Individually-Packaged Portions | No |
| Lactose-Free | Yes |
| Low-Carb | Yes |
| Milk-Free | No |
| Net Weight | 24 oz |
| Paleo-Friendly | No |
| Product Type | Specialty Cheese |
| Seasoned | No |
| Sugar-Free | No |
| Variety Pack | No |
| Vegetarian | Yes |
| Weight of One Each | 24 |
| upc | 078354719121 |
| Free_Shipping | N |
| Preparation | Block |
| Quantity | 24 oz. |
| Country of Origin | USA |
| Allergen Risk(s) | Milk |
| Gluten Free | Yes |
| Ingredient(s) | See Above |
| Kosher | Yes |
| Lactose Free | Yes |
| Lite | No |
| Low Sodium | No |
| Organic | No |
| Unit Size | 1.5 lbs. |
| Vegan | No |
$10
$729
$1499
$849
$1584 - $2376
Cabot Seriously Sharp Cheddar, 24 oz.
