Peanut Butter & Jelly(26 Results)

Filter By

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases

using the BJ's One+™ Mastercard^®.

Learn More

with no risk to your credit score

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases¹.

Check if you’re pre-approved

with no risk to your

credit score.

Learn More

Sort & Filter
Coupons
Instant Rebates
Reset

Sort By

Relevance

Grid
List

Best Seller

^$5³⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Welch's Grape Jelly, 2 pk./30 oz.

348

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Sponsored

^$9⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smash Foods Cherry Pomegranate Superfood Fruit Spread, 60% Less Sugar, Non-GMO, Jar, 26 oz

$1.00 off

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

2788

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 ct./26 oz.

$1.65 off

382

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Crofter's Organic Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

279

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 36 oz.

608

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$19⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Uncrustables Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Sandwiches, Frozen, 10g Protein, 18 ct./2.8 oz.

560

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$19⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Uncrustables Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam Sandwiches, 10g Protein, Frozen, 18 ct./2.8 oz.

145

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Best Seller

^$15⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Creamy Hazelnut Spread, Breakfast Favorite, Jars, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

359

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$14⁹⁹

$16.99

$2.00 (11%) Off

Instant Savings

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella & Go! Hazelnut Spread with Breadsticks, On-the-Go Snack Cups, Snack Packs, 16 ct./1.8 oz.

301

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Top Rated

^$11⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

1774

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$7⁹⁸

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Strawberry Preserves, 2 pk./32 oz.

413

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$7⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Almond Butter with Sea Salt, 27 oz.

$1.00 off

380

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$10⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves, 26 oz.

412

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Top Rated

^$12⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Chunky Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

2117

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

8g of Protein

^$8⁹⁸

SNAP EBT Eligible

PBfit Classic Roasted Peanut Powder, 8g Protein Per Serving, 30oz.

237

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$10⁴⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Stonewall Kitchen Wild Maine Blueberry Jam, 30 oz.

315

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$15⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella B-ready Wafer Bars, Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Individually Wrapped Snack Bars, 36 ct./0.7 oz.

311

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

Top Rated

^$13⁷⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz

989

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

6g of Protein

^$10⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

PB2 Original Powdered Peanut Butter, 6g Protein Per Serving, 30 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$8⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Sunbutter Creamy Sunflower Seed Butter, 28 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$13¹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Roasted Peanut Spread With Cocoa, Smooth and Creamy Spread, Jars, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$7⁹⁸

SNAP EBT Eligible

NuttZo Power Fuel Crunchy Nut & Seed Butter, 16 oz.

Pickup at Willoughby
Delivery to
Shipping

^$4⁹⁹

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Goober Grape, Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Stripes, Jar, 30 oz.

Currently Unavailable

Nostalgic Favorite 📼

Showing 26 of 26 Results

^$6³⁹

Welch's Grape Jelly, 2 pk./30 oz.

(348)

^$10⁹⁹

Smash Foods Raspberry Superfood Fruit Spread, 26 oz.

(100)

^$9²⁹

Wellsley Farms Premium Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 10 IB

(570)

^$12⁷⁹

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

(2788)

^$8⁹⁹

Sunbutter Creamy Sunflower Seed Butter, 28 oz.

(21)

^$14⁴⁹

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal, 49.5 oz.

$1.00 OFF

(2980)

^$15²⁹

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, Jars, 2 pk./48 oz.

(4047)

^$11⁹⁹

NuttZo Power Fuel Crunchy Nut & Seed Butter, 16 oz.

(34)

^$10⁹⁹

General Mills Honey Nut Cheerios, 55 oz.

$1.00 OFF

(1085)

^$8⁷⁹

Pearl Milling Company Original Pancake Syrup, 64 oz.

$5.00 off 2

(568)

^$11⁹⁹

Kellogg's Frosted Flakes Breakfast Cereal, 2 pk.

$2.00 off

(1651)

^$16⁴⁹

Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Creamy Hazelnut Spread, Breakfast Favorite, Jars, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

(359)

^$13²⁹

Pearl Milling Company Complete Buttermilk Pancake and Waffle Mix, 2 pk./5 lbs.

$5.00 off 2

(286)

^$17⁷⁹

Wellsley Farms Organic Grade A Dark Maple Syrup, 32 oz.

(772)

^$11²⁹

Post Honey Bunches of Oats with Almonds, 48 oz.

$1.50 off

(604)

^$18⁴⁹

Nestle Toll House Semi-Sweet Chocolate Morsels, Chocolate Chips, Gluten Free, 72 oz.

$1.00 off

(3180)

^$6⁹⁹

Domino Light Brown Sugar, 4 lbs.

(264)

^$9²⁹

Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 36 oz.

(608)

^$8²⁹

Cap'n Crunch's Crunch Berries Sweetened Corn & Oat Cereal, 2 pk./20 oz.

(340)

^$12⁷⁹

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

(1774)

^$11⁹⁹

Purely Elizabeth Ancient Grain Granola Gluten Free Non-GMO Organic Original, 24 oz.

$2.00 off

(365)

^$9⁷⁹

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 ct./26 oz.

$1.65 off

(382)

^$9⁷⁹

Post Fruity Pebbles Crispy Rice Cereal, 2 pk./19 oz.

(296)

^$9⁹⁹

Smash Foods Cherry Pomegranate Superfood Fruit Spread, 60% Less Sugar, Non-GMO, Jar, 26 oz.

$1.00 off

(22)

^$9²⁹

General Mills Cheerios, 40.7 oz.

$1.00 OFF

(1014)

^$13⁹⁹

Smucker's Strawberry Preserves, 2 pk./32 oz.

(413)

^$12⁹⁹

Quaker Oats Quick 1-Minute Oats, 2 pk./5 lbs.

(375)

^$11⁴⁹

Wellsley Farms Honey, 40 oz.

(591)

^$7⁹⁹

Lucky Charms, Cookie Crisp, Trix Cereal Variety Pack, 3 pk.

$1.00 OFF

(250)

^$8⁹⁹

Crofter's Organic Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

(279)

Peanut Butter & Jelly(26 Results)

^$6³⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$12⁷⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$14⁴⁹

^$15²⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$8⁷⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$16⁴⁹

^$13²⁹

^$17⁷⁹

^$11²⁹

^$18⁴⁹

^$6⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$8²⁹

^$12⁷⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$9⁷⁹

^$9⁷⁹

^$9⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$13⁹⁹

^$12⁹⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$7⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹

Join Today

Shopping

Member Care

Membership

Our Company

Peanut Butter & Jelly(26 Results)

$639

$1099

$929

$1279

$899

$1449

$1529

$1199

$1099

$879

$1199

$1649

$1329

$1779

$1129

$1849

$699

$929

$829

$1279

$1199

$979

$979

$999

$929

$1399

$1299

$1149

$799

$899

^$6³⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$12⁷⁹

^$8⁹⁹

^$14⁴⁹

^$15²⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$10⁹⁹

^$8⁷⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$16⁴⁹

^$13²⁹

^$17⁷⁹

^$11²⁹

^$18⁴⁹

^$6⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$8²⁹

^$12⁷⁹

^$11⁹⁹

^$9⁷⁹

^$9⁷⁹

^$9⁹⁹

^$9²⁹

^$13⁹⁹

^$12⁹⁹

^$11⁴⁹

^$7⁹⁹

^$8⁹⁹