Peanut Butter & Jelly(25 Results)

Filter By

Delivery Options

Special Offers

Product Type

Brands

Flavor

Dietary Needs

Average Rating

EBT Eligible

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases

using the BJ's One+™ Mastercard®.

Learn More

with no risk to your credit score

Earn 5% back in rewards on most BJ’s purchases1.

Check if you’re pre-approved

with no risk to your

credit score.

Learn More

Relevance
Top Rated

$1279

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping
Top Rated
7g of Protein

$1479

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, Jars, 2 pk./48 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping
Top Rated

$899

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 36 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$539

SNAP EBT Eligible

Welch's Grape Jelly, 2 pk./30 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$1599

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, Creamy Hazelnut Spread, Breakfast Favorite, Jars, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

$2.50 off
  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping
Top Rated

$1279

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$999

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Strawberry Jam, Made with Ripe Strawberries, Easy to Spread, Jars, 2 pk./32 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Not available for shippingShipping

$839

$9.89

$1.50 (15%) Off

Instant Savings

SNAP EBT Eligible

Crofter's Organic Premium Spread, Strawberry, 41 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Not available for shippingShipping

$929

SNAP EBT Eligible

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, 2 ct./26 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping
Top Rated

$1999

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Uncrustables Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Sandwiches, Frozen, 11g Protein, 18 ct./2.8 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Not available for shippingShipping

$999

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smash Foods Cherry Pomegranate Superfood Fruit Spread, 60% Less Sugar, Non-GMO, Jar, 26 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Not available for shippingShipping
6g of Protein

$1099

SNAP EBT Eligible

PB2 Original Powdered Peanut Butter, 6g Protein Per Serving, 30 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$1499

$16.99

$2.00 (11%) Off

Instant Savings

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella & Go! Hazelnut Spread with Breadsticks, On-the-Go Snack Cups, Snack Packs, 16 ct./1.8 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$1149

SNAP EBT Eligible

Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves, 26 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping
Top Rated

$1279

SNAP EBT Eligible

Skippy Chunky Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$1129

SNAP EBT Eligible

Wellsley Farms Almond Butter with Sea Salt, 27 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping
Top Rated

$1479

SNAP EBT Eligible

Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 2 pk./48 oz

  • Not available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Not available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$898

SNAP EBT Eligible

Nutella Roasted Peanut Spread With Cocoa, Smooth and Creamy Spread, Jars, 2 pk./26.5 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$1499

SNAP EBT Eligible

Stonewall Kitchen Premium Jams Holiday Variety Pack, Red Pepper, Holiday, Apricot, 3 pk./12.25 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Not available for shippingShipping

$798

SNAP EBT Eligible

Sunbutter Creamy Sunflower Seed Butter, 28 oz.

  • Available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$1199

SNAP EBT Eligible

NuttZo Power Fuel Crunchy Nut & Seed Butter, 16 oz.

  • Not available for pickup at Jersey CityPickup at Jersey City
  • Not available for delivery to undefinedDelivery to
  • Available for shippingShipping

$499

SNAP EBT Eligible

Smucker's Goober Grape, Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly Stripes, Jar, 30 oz.

    Currently Unavailable

Nostalgic Favorite 📼

Showing 25 of 25 Results

Related Categories

You May Also Like
(30 Items)